Blog 5: Modern Day Witch Trials

As we start our conversations on the Salem Witch Trials, it has led me to ponder on some examples of modern day witch hunts and witch trials. While there aren’t many situations to compare to in the literal sence, with those accused being hanged or murdered for their crimes, there are some that are similar in their core accusations and evidentiary basis. Most notably, I wanted to investigate the similarities and differences of modern “cancel culture” to that of the Salem witch trials; specifically looking at who is accused, why they were accused, and the consequences they face for these accusations. 

I found an article that I believe portrays the two phenomena in a very insightful manner, here is my analysis of this article and the concept as a whole: 

This article addresses the phenomenon of "cancel culture," which refers to the widespread trend of publicly denouncing and ostracizing individuals or entities deemed to have engaged in offensive behavior or held controversial views. The author explores historical instances of similar behavior, such as the Salem Witch Trials, drawing parallels to the contemporary issue of cancel culture.

The article criticizes cancel culture for its perceived lack of nuance and forgiveness, highlighting cases where individuals face severe consequences for past actions or statements, even if they occurred in their youth or were taken out of context. The author argues that cancel culture stifles freedom of expression and does not allow for growth or redemption, likening it to a "witch hunt" mentality. I found the fates of the accused in both situations can be compared. On the one hand, the accused witches of Salem lost their lives tragically due to the outcomes of their trials. While those who are accused in cancel culture are not physically hanged for their “crimes,” oftentimes their lives are lost in the form of their reputations, occupations, and personal lives suffer greatly

Additionally, I found there to be many similarities in the use of spectral evidence in both cancel culture and, as we know, in the Salem witch hunts. Spectral evidence, a form of legal evidence based upon the testimony of those who claim to have experienced visions, was used frequently in testimonies during the witch trials of the 16th and 17th centuries. This was taken as evidence that the accused witches, and or devils or demons that assumed appearance, were actively tormenting the victims, and this testimony was virtually impossible to refute. Similarly, many who fall victim to modern cancel culture are acused on the basis of intangible or outdated evidence. Once the masses deem them as guilty, the accused fate is scealed, and there is essentially no way to refute the claims.

Overall, the article presents a critical perspective on cancel culture, drawing on historical precedents and contemporary examples to argue against its prevalence in society. I agree with the testimonies of this article; however, while I do think that it is very important to hold people accountable for their past or present actions, I believe there needs to be room for personal growth and potential acceptance.

Article: https://www.sctimes.com/story/opinion/2021/04/09/cancel-culture-just-another-phrase-witch-hunt/7148581002/